G’s Evaluation or The Football Season is Almost Over!

Welcome back, college sports fans, to episode 756 which is all about football. The FCS regular season is complete (except for two SWAC games next week). The SWAC championship game is still on the schedule between Alabama A&M and Prairie View. The winner of that game will take on SC St, who won the MEAC title, in the Celebration Bowl on December 12th. The playoffs also begin next Saturday which is a pretty good preview of what the FBS 24-team playoff will look like next year.

…..

Speaking of the FBS, the final week of the regular season, or rivalry week, begins Tuesday night with a little more MACNation action, and ends with an 11:00pm Eastern kickoff when Sacramento St heads to Hawaii. The last few years of bowl proliferation has caused a specific issue for at least one team. Needing 82 (including the 12 playoff) teams to fill the 42 (including the playoff) bowls has been an issue. Rice has been a 5-7 (destined to be 5-8) bowl team a few times in the last few years. The rule is that bowl teams need to be 6-6 or better, unless there are not enough. If a conference championship loser fell to 6-7 in that game, they would be up next. Then Hawaii, if they are 6-7, followed by other 6-7 teams. Then using an academic ranking, the 5-7 teams with the highest score are offered next, until enough accept to fill the slots. This season we will not have that problem.

…..

As of yesterday’s games, 82 teams have already clinched bowl eligibility. If no one else qualifies next week, we have the teams. More on that in a moment. First, let’s congratulate (in no particular order) Tulane, Virginia, Stanford, Cincinnati, UCF, Minnesota, Michigan, Mid Tenn, Delaware, UCONN, Oregon St, Fresno St, Marshall, and South Alabama for reaching the 6-win milestone. With the good comes the not-so-much as 17 teams will miss bowl season (for sure since we already have 82 qualifiers). 16 of them picked up their 7th loss: E Michigan, Kansas, Kansas St, Colorado, Maryland, W Kentucky, Missouri St, FIU, San Jose St, Utah St, Arkansas, Texas A&M, Vanderbilt, Coastal, Troy, and Arkansas St). UMASS is the 17th team despite having a 5-6 record because two of their wins were against FCS teams, and only one counts towards bowl eligibility. There are 13 teams sitting on 5-6 with their post-season fates resting, in part, on next week’s performance. They are with their opponents in parenthesis North Carolina (NC St), NC St (at North Carolina), Boston College (at Miami FL), Florida St (Florida), Syracuse (Notre Dame), TCU (at Texas Tech), West Virginia (at Utah), Iowa St (Kansas St), Kennesaw St (at W Kentucky), C Michigan (at Ball St), Nevada (at UNLV), Mississippi St (at Mississippi), and Georgia St (Louisiana). Army is 5-5 and is at Rice next week before facing Navy on December 12th. A win clinches a spot, while a loss puts the pressure on the ultimate annual rivalry game. Navy is 4-6 and must win at Charlotte next weekend AND beat Army to qualify. It is possible that both will be left out, if Army loses Saturday, due to timing and an excess of qualified teams.

…..

Over the summer, we contemplated dropping the against the spread calculation for two reasons: 1) we do not encourage gambling on college (or any) sports, and 2) the regression is either hit or miss – some years the GCR crushes it and looks like genius and other years, using the same basic logic, the GCR fails in the worst way. The inconsistency, without us being able to locate the “why” behind it leads to our frustration. If we were always “bad”, we could change the logic. That’s not the case here. We got some feedback from a dear friend that he liked the metric and seeing the accuracy play out, so we kept it in for this season. However, we have made the decision to shift to a more basketball like prediction model set that eliminates the against the spread calcs while reinforcing the confidence of the GCR’s straight up picks. That will include the occasional Too Close to Call non-prediction when the two metrics disagree on the winner. Of the 130 games last week, there were only 5 that would have had the conflict. That said, we will continue to use this year’s modeling through the bowl season and playoffs. This past week, we had our best straight up record since Week 4 with a 93-35 (727) rate despite yet another mini upset week. Against the spread, however, continued to disappoint going just 52-68 (433), the worst week of the season. Overall, the GCR has predicted 1,304 games going 870-434 (667) while mustering just a 572-540 (514) record against the spread in the 1,112 games predicted.

WeekC4/C4C4/G6C4/FCSG6/G6G6/FCSFCS/FCSTotal
0———————
1———0-2 (000)
0-2 (000)
3-0 (1000)
2-1 (667)
15-8 (652)
12-9 (571)
18-10 (643) 14-12 (538)
29-5 (643)
6-8 (429)
16-1 (941) 11-6 (647)8-8 (500)
9-7 (563)
15-1 (938)
10-6 (625)
14-7 (667)
8-12 (400)
21-12 (636)
12-21 (364)
83-34 (709) 56-60 (483)
313-7 (650)
10-10 (500)
18-1 (947) 9-10 (474)9-0 (1000)
6-3 (667)
8-10 (444)
8-10 (444)
8-1 (889)
3-6 (333)
23-13 (639)
17-14 (548)
79-32 (712) 53-53 (500)
413-10 (565) 17-6 (739)7-2 (778)
6-3 (667)
3-0 (1000)
3-0 (1000)
16-5 (762)
13-8 (619)
8-1 (889)
5-4 (556)
35-13 (729)
30-18 (625)
82-31 (726) 74-39 (655)
517-10 (630) 16-11 (593)2-0 (1000) 2-1 (667)1-0 (1000)
0-1 (000)
19-7 (731)
18-8 (692)
2-0 (1000)
2-0 (1000)
33-20 (623)
28-20 (583)
74-37 (667) 66-41 (617)
617-9 (654)
14-12 (538)
1-1 (500)
0-2 (000)
—18-13 (581) 15-15 (500) —28-18 (609)
22-22 (500)
64-41 (610) 51-51 (500)
713-15 (464)
9-19 (321)
—3-0 (1000)
0-2 (000)
22-9 (710)
16-15 (516)
—32-21 (604)
13-13 (500)
70-45 (609) 38-49 (437)
815-12 (556) 14-13 (519) — —19-9 (679)
17-12 (586)
—36-19 (655)
16-18 (471)
70-40 (636) 47-43 (522)
920-8 (714)
11-17 (393)
2-0 (1000) 1-1 (500) —19-7 (731)
12-14 (462)
—42-15 (737)
14-14 (500)
83-30 (735) 38-46 (452)
1017-13 (567) 15-15 (500)1-0 (1000) 0-1 (000)1-0 (1000)
1-0 (1000)
20-11 (645) 12-19 (387) —38-24 (613)
19-11 (633)
77-48 (616) 47-46 (505)
1122-12 (647) 17-17 (500) — —20-13 (606) 19-14 (576) —35-26 (574)
0-1 (000)
77-51 (602) 36-32 (529)
1223-9 (719)
17-15 (531)
—4-0 (1000)
1-3 (250)
25-9 (735)
15-19 (441)
—41-17 (707)
19-31 (380)
93-35 (727) 52-68 (433)
Total179-110 (619) 146-143 (505)47-5 (904) 29-24 (547)29-8 (784) 20-16 (556)201-96 (677) 155-142 (522)35-9 (795) 20-23 (465)379-206 (648) 202-192 (513)870-434 (667) 572-540 (514)

…..

All of that analysis said and done, the primary purpose of the weekly Evaluation is a look at the GCR ranking of the 266 Division I teams. With some unexpected losses to Indiana and UCLA, we have a new number one team in the Georgia Bulldogs, who have been in the top AP and Playoff spot for a number of weeks. We also have a new bottom-dweller with hapless VMI taking that spot. Here’s a look at all 266.

RankTeamConfWinLossPFPAScoreRPICelsius
1GeorgiaSEC10141.113.917.484100.00
2Miami FLACC10142.619.817.40599.68
3Notre DameND10138.112.817.06298.28
4UtahB1211037.918.516.49195.96
5Wake ForestACC10144.516.316.32795.28
6AlabamaSEC9236.817.215.85993.34
7UCLAB1010130.914.515.36691.37
8Texas TechB1210137.323.114.96889.72
9TexasSEC9231.516.514.61388.30
10TennesseeSEC9231.014.214.221186.74
11BYUB129230.719.513.951085.63
12OregonB108334.819.413.861385.25
13Ohio StB107434.319.513.782084.93
14IndianaB109231.213.813.601284.19
15ArizonaB128334.722.513.522283.86
16IowaB109228.412.213.481483.71
17HoustonB128335.024.113.161882.41
18LouisvilleACC8338.623.412.981781.69
19LibertyUSA10133.914.512.856981.16
20WisconsinB107425.716.512.312878.96
21LSUSEC6533.518.912.162778.35
22Southern CalB108330.924.211.981577.60
23MississippiSEC7434.525.011.952177.49
24Boise StPAC9237.926.411.805976.88
25Oklahoma StB127441.129.511.792676.85
26New MexicoMWC9232.012.411.736876.61
27MissouriSEC7429.222.111.502575.65
28OklahomaSEC7422.817.911.461675.50
29NebraskaB107430.416.111.453375.45
30DukeACC7430.215.711.443175.40
31North Dakota StMWC9227.713.211.407275.25
32FloridaSEC7431.526.310.791972.78
33BaylorB126527.618.310.773972.71
34LA TechSUN9237.519.810.766772.64
35SMUACC7431.225.410.593071.96
36James MadisonSUN8338.921.710.578271.88
37AuburnSEC7429.023.910.392471.15
38NorthwesternB106528.620.210.264170.60
39MemphisAAC8338.526.510.207870.38
40KentuckySEC7427.025.510.042369.73
41UTSAAAC9231.927.49.976069.45
42WashingtonB107425.921.49.823568.83
43Air ForceMWC9230.418.19.807168.75
44South CarolinaSEC6529.525.49.783468.68
45Penn StB106529.619.49.704468.33
46LouisianaSUN8331.721.99.588567.86
47StanfordACC6524.335.19.553867.74
48ToledoMAC9232.920.09.387667.03
49VirginiaACC6528.221.79.344266.86
50Ga SouthernSUN7428.918.39.338066.85
51W MichiganMAC8328.419.59.317766.76
52MichiganB106518.317.59.262966.55
53ClemsonACC7420.919.69.243266.46
54CincinnatiB126531.430.49.213666.35
55Texas StPAC7438.729.69.177366.16
56Iowa StB125629.229.29.114565.93
57PittsburghACC6527.921.59.114665.91
58North CarolinaACC5625.623.89.074865.78
59North TexasAAC7440.231.09.017965.55
60Virginia TechACC6531.825.78.905065.10
61TulsaAAC7434.421.88.849364.82
62IllinoisB106526.123.98.773764.56
63Florida StACC5627.526.68.755164.45
64Arizona StB126528.126.38.664764.11
65Jax StUSA8328.320.68.578863.73
66BuffaloMAC8325.723.88.498163.40
67UNLVMWC7425.524.58.378362.94
68OhioMAC8328.823.48.368662.88
69TCUB125622.817.38.125461.92
70UCFB126530.225.28.124361.90
71MinnesotaB106523.323.48.024061.51
72Oregon StPAC6537.628.47.979061.31
73Fresno StPAC6529.524.07.969561.25
74Montana StSKY11139.819.47.7414260.35
75KansasB124730.124.47.696460.15
76FAUAAC7438.033.47.678760.06
77Boston CollegeACC5621.027.27.535559.51
78ArkansasSEC4719.727.17.485359.31
79WyomingMWC7421.921.37.399658.93
80Mississippi StSEC5625.427.97.284958.49
81Texas A&MSEC4722.619.87.246258.35
82Miami OHMAC7427.423.67.188958.09
83Steph F AustinSLAN11142.513.87.0416257.52
84TarletonUAC12038.822.86.9914157.32
85East CarolinaAAC7421.721.16.919456.97
86NevadaMWC5621.020.66.8710956.80
87ArmyAAC5529.623.86.8610256.77
88C MichiganMAC5620.623.76.8210356.63
89South FloridaAAC6526.220.36.7410756.31
90West VirginiaB125634.534.76.715256.16
91NC StACC5629.026.56.705656.11
92SyracuseACC5628.526.16.656155.92
93UABAAC6522.622.16.6210155.82
94South AlabamaSUN6532.630.86.609955.74
95ColoradoB124722.529.36.565755.54
96Michigan StB103817.725.36.406354.91
97UCONNIND6533.725.76.389854.82
98DelawareUSA6530.828.06.3710454.79
99San Diego StPAC6526.431.16.309154.49
100NavyAAC4630.130.86.1410553.84
101PurdueB103825.632.86.066553.51
102South Dakota StMFC10239.415.95.8914352.83
103VanderbiltSEC4721.829.15.865852.72
104Utah StPAC4717.222.45.8210852.56
105Georgia StSUN5632.227.15.7711252.37
106MarylandB104726.730.75.646651.83
107App StSUN7424.922.95.619751.69
108Kennesaw StUSA5626.124.95.5211151.31
109Mid TennUSA6526.930.55.3110650.47
110UMASSMAC5625.123.45.2712350.29
111HarvardIVY8227.714.55.1617549.86
112LehighPAT10232.820.25.0718449.52
113MarshallSUN6522.330.45.0110049.24
114FIUUSA4719.522.04.9911849.18
115Kansas StB124729.126.94.967449.05
116W KentuckyUSA4723.633.54.8211048.49
117TulaneAAC6521.627.64.749248.17
118San Jose StMWC5719.522.34.6011347.57
119LamarSLAN10233.922.84.3614546.62
120ButlerPFL10232.216.94.3621346.59
121South DakotaMFC9334.323.54.2914746.32
122Georgia TechACC3824.031.54.287046.30
123DaytonPFL10132.718.94.2321646.10
124AlbanyCAA8427.319.14.2216446.02
125Idaho StSKY7531.322.04.1919145.93
126Youngstown StMFC8339.925.64.1414045.72
127Alabama A&MSWAC9337.320.34.0820945.46
128SC StMEAC10239.818.34.0219345.24
129CoastalSUN4724.925.53.9111544.80
130Arkansas StSUN4724.628.53.9012144.72
131E MichiganMAC4720.527.33.4611742.95
132CaliforniaACC3821.133.13.457542.91
133Incarnate WordSLAN8441.123.63.4316942.83
134Missouri StUSA4723.828.73.4212242.81
135Bowling GreenMAC3817.528.03.3912442.68
136TN TechSoCon9333.622.93.2914942.25
137RutgersB103823.431.53.268442.14
138North DakotaMFC8435.125.23.1914641.87
139Austin PeayUAC8434.021.43.1217141.58
140MercerSoCon10229.418.33.0814841.40
141HawaiiMWC3818.522.53.0712041.38
142Illinois StMFC8431.219.72.8618040.50
143St ThomasPFL9334.325.62.8313940.39
144MontanaSKY8437.929.42.8216640.35
145N ArizonaSKY9331.827.42.7814440.20
146MonmouthCAA9332.329.12.7215039.95
147TroySUN4720.228.02.6911639.82
148Jackson StSWAC8335.522.12.6122539.51
149YaleIVY6427.021.12.5321439.19
150W IllinoisBSOV8437.322.82.5116039.08
151CampbellCAA8434.930.22.5015239.05
152Old DominionSUN3817.226.12.4211938.72
153RiceAAC2921.732.12.3913038.61
154Ball StMAC3821.934.22.3412538.38
155ColgatePAT7520.115.42.2419437.97
156BrownIVY6420.817.12.2122837.85
157PrincetonIVY6417.616.72.0721237.29
158ChattanoogaSoCon7519.115.62.0515737.21
159Kent StMAC3814.529.81.7812936.13
160VillanovaPAT7527.924.31.6816735.72
161BryantCAA8422.321.01.6717835.68
162DartmouthIVY5520.319.41.6022635.39
163Southern MissSUN3827.636.81.5312835.10
164Ark Pine BluffSWAC7434.427.21.4415834.73
165Colorado StPAC3833.747.71.4211434.67
166C ConnecticutNEC6532.028.21.3419234.31
167Washington StPAC2923.526.91.3412634.31
168Weber StSKY8434.830.81.3316334.29
169San DiegoPFL6533.834.21.2924734.11
170CornellIVY4628.627.11.2524833.96
171North AlabamaUAC7523.821.11.0817233.28
172SEMOBSOV7527.325.41.0817733.25
173New Mexico StUSA3821.527.41.0613133.18
174E Tenn StSoCon7530.323.41.0217633.01
175UC DavisSKY8430.530.80.7915432.08
176S UtahSKY6633.328.90.7520631.92
177SELASLAN6625.426.30.7318831.85
178Stony BrookCAA6630.529.40.7122931.76
179Prairie ViewSWAC7526.424.60.6916831.68
180AkronMAC2920.033.20.6612731.58
181DuquesneNEC6522.522.80.6016531.31
182IdahoSKY5730.732.90.5815631.25
183MaristPFL6623.721.80.5825431.21
184ValparaisoPFL5625.222.50.5725231.18
185W CarolinaSoCon7528.927.70.4816130.84
186Holy CrossPAT7523.825.40.4218730.57
187TempleAAC2923.729.30.3813430.42
188Sam HoustonUSA11017.527.70.3713830.38
189Alabama StSWAC6524.722.30.1921529.66
190PennIVY5518.620.90.1923829.65
191ElonCAA6622.818.90.1221829.34
192West FloridaUAC5523.122.90.1123929.33
193Gardner WebbBSOV3919.323.80.0420729.03
194NC CentralMEAC6626.726.70.0321028.99
195ULMSUN2919.833.8-0.0113328.85
196CharlotteAAC11018.836.7-0.0713528.58
197Abilene ChrUAC6626.726.4-0.1215128.40
198SouthernSWAC6528.329.6-0.1417028.32
199Rio GrandeSLAN6624.324.8-0.1520128.25
200Robert MorrisNEC6621.823.3-0.2024928.07
201Sacred HeartCAA5624.625.9-0.2223327.98
202Rhode IslandCAA5721.224.0-0.2424027.89
203FurmanSoCon4818.019.3-0.3320527.55
204Alcorn StSWAC6641.135.7-0.6123426.40
205N IllinoisMWC01116.535.5-0.6413726.26
206RichmondPAT7517.724.6-0.6618326.18
207Sacramento StMAC2916.129.2-0.6613626.17
208WoffordSoCon5721.825.0-0.8517925.41
209E KentuckyUAC4823.331.3-0.9721924.94
210NC A&TCAA5720.025.4-0.9823724.89
211UTEPMWC11013.235.3-1.0013224.80
212N IowaMFC4725.032.0-1.1318524.28
213Norfolk StMEAC5729.822.9-1.2326123.89
214DrakePFL3826.636.7-1.2626223.74
215S IllinoisMFC5723.328.1-1.2718623.71
216C ArkansasUAC5725.627.2-1.3920223.21
217Delaware StMEAC6623.025.9-1.4022223.20
218N ColoradoSKY3922.227.8-1.4224523.09
219Morgan StMEAC6624.528.3-1.4419023.02
220PresbyterianPFL4724.035.5-1.4525922.96
221McNeeseSLAN5720.323.4-1.4819922.86
222LindenwoodBSOV5623.526.4-1.4920422.82
223LafayettePAT4723.730.5-1.5023622.78
224ColumbiaIVY5522.831.5-1.5324322.66
225GramblingSWAC5534.135.4-1.5619822.51
226UT MartinBSOV6626.233.1-1.6315522.22
227E IllinoisBSOV4819.528.6-1.8122021.50
228GeorgetownPAT3719.428.0-1.8525321.35
229StonehillNEC4817.623.6-1.9622320.89
230BethuneSWAC5724.732.7-2.2022119.92
231Houston ChrSLAN5723.325.6-2.2620019.68
232Cal PolySKY4825.935.5-2.3524119.30
233TowsonCAA4826.230.9-2.3819719.18
234FordhamPAT4819.027.5-2.4320819.01
235SamfordSoCon4818.325.4-2.4417418.95
236New HavenNEC3914.727.3-2.4425618.95
237Morehead StPFL3925.637.8-2.4626518.88
238New HampshireCAA5720.229.8-2.6021118.29
239Florida A&MSWAC4819.831.3-2.6220318.22
240Chrls SoBSOV4822.224.3-2.6218118.20
241TN StBSOV4815.327.9-2.6319518.18
242William & MaryPAT4820.032.1-2.7922717.50
243East TexasSLAN3918.132.5-2.8024417.50
244E WashingtonSKY3929.139.8-2.8122417.44
245Long IslandNEC5715.623.8-2.8518217.26
246HowardMEAC5719.030.6-2.9415916.91
247DavidsonPFL4820.134.8-3.0026416.65
248MerrimackFCSIND5716.832.0-3.0915316.32
249Chicago StFCSIND3829.435.6-3.2826315.52
250StetsonPFL11123.842.9-3.8726613.15
251Utah TechSKY11120.337.2-4.1024212.19
252CitadelSoCon3919.031.8-4.1223012.11
253TX SouthernSWAC3822.839.3-4.1423212.02
254BucknellPAT11113.528.3-4.2125111.76
255MaineCAA11013.128.4-4.2623511.55
256Indiana StMFC21022.838.0-4.4724610.67
257Portland StSKY3922.841.8-4.5617310.31
258Murray StMFC3921.838.3-4.6118910.10
259WagnerNEC4816.833.2-4.6219610.09
260MercyhurstNEC21021.836.2-4.672179.89
261MS ValleySWAC3916.535.8-4.812579.32
262NichollsSLAN4816.536.9-5.622316.01
263Nwestern StSLAN01216.847.5-5.652585.89
264West GeorgiaUAC11113.834.5-6.902500.78
265HamptonCAA11114.934.9-6.942550.63
266VMISoCon0129.339.9-7.102600.00

…..

That’s it for today. Tune in tomorrow for another double feature that includes not only all the men’s and women’s basketball games in the morning, but also the women’s Top 363 in the evening. Until then, thank you for reading, taking the time to comment, and, especially, for sharing with others, JoJo and G.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *